Would Calvin Coolidge Approve of Donald Trump?
Calvin Coolidge, often referred to as the 'silent' president, leaves a lasting impression on American history for his concise and reserved nature. In stark contrast, former President Donald Trump is known for his verbosity and even-handed critiques. This juxtaposition raises the intriguing question: would Coolidge, with his staid style of governance, have an opinion on Trump and, if so, what would it be?
Personality vs. Policies
The political landscape of the 1920s and the early 21st century shares some interesting parallels. While Coolidge was a man of few words and unfailingly respectful, Trump's campaign and presidency often involved assertions and blunt honesty, albeit often controversial. Complicating matters, Coolidge upheld a modest and respectful demeanor, which contrasts sharply with Trump's more narcissistic and attention-seeking behavior.
Arguments for Dislike
Self-centeredness: Coolidge was a modest man, far less ego-driven than Trump. The self-promotion and constant demand for attention that characterized Trump’s presidency would have been off-putting to Coolidge, who valued privacy and personal restraint.
Scandals and Misconduct: The controversies and scandals in the Trump administration would have been a significant point of concern for Coolidge, who served under a scandal-plagued presidency as Vice President in the Harding administration.
Isolationism: Trump’s more confrontational approach to international relations, including his stance on Iran and defense spending, would have starkly differed from Coolidge's more isolationist views.
Immigration Policies: It is worth noting that both men share a restrictive view towards immigration, though the specifics and methods differ. Coolidge signed the Johnson-Reed Act, one of the most restrictive immigration laws in U.S. history, while Trump’s rhetoric on immigration and visa laws mirrors a similar philosophy.
Alignment in Policies
Despite their personal differences, Coolidge and Trump share several policy similarities. Both supported a limited and interventionist government, a robust economy, and a strong belief in personal responsibility. Additionally, they were both staunch Republicans who vehemently opposed socialism and communism. These shared ideological roots suggest that Coolidge would have had a basis to vote for Trump on the policy front.
Challenges in Support
National Debt: Coolidge would likely be disappointed by how Trump's tenure has contributed to a rise in the national debt, an area where personal frugality and fiscal responsibility were hallmarks of Coolidge’s administration.
Pro-War Stance: Trump’s push for military action and warmongering would have been at odds with Coolidge’s isolationist stance, which preferred a more defensive and less confrontational approach to American foreign policy.
Tax Policies: Coolidge would have approved of Trump’s tax cuts for the wealthy, as both believed in a hands-off approach to economic policies that favored wealth generation and accumulation.
Conclusion
In summary, while Coolidge’s public persona and personality would have been at odds with Trump’s more bombastic and self-absorbed style, their shared policies and ideological beliefs suggest that Coolidge would have found some aspects of Trump's presidency to be acceptable. However, personal virtues and the moderation and frugality of Coolidge would have likely led him to advise Trump to 'Talk less. Spend less.' as his four-word instruction to the current president.