Why Jhatka Meat Continues to Dominate the Indian Market Despite Halal’s Rise
Why Jhatka Meat Continues to Dominate the Indian Market Despite Halal’s Rise is a pressing issue that has sparked debate and tension in various social and economic spheres. The discussion centers around the two main methods of animal slaughter in India: Jhatka and Halal. It is crucial to understand these methods, the reasons behind the backlash against Big Basket, and the underlying cultural and economic factors at play.
Understanding the Two Meat Slaughter Methods
In India, there are two primary methods of meat production:
Jhatka: This method involves beheading the animal in one swift stroke. It is preferred by Hindus and Sikhs because it ensures a quick and non-traumatic death for the animal.
Halal: This method involves slowly cutting the jugular and carotid first, allowing the blood to drain out. It is the preferred method for Muslims as it also ensures a quick and painless death for the animal.
Image Source: Google
While both methods aim to achieve a quick and humane death, they are governed by different religious and cultural practices. The continuous debate over the sale of Halal meat by Big Basket is an example of the tension that exists in this context.
The Arguments Surrounding Big Basket's Decision
A recent tweet from Big Basket sparked a heated debate. Some individuals criticized the company for only selling the Jhatka method of meat, while others defended the move.
A mock response to the criticism is: Forget all your tensions… when I'm there to sing beautiful melodies for you, S one beautiful song… demand more songs you like.
The backlash has been characterized by false equivalency, with some users trying to drown out the discussion with Islamophobic rhetoric. It is important to understand that the focus on Jhatka sales is not about economic boycotts but about the prevalence of Halal standards in the market.
False Equivalency and Economic Boycotts
The argument that Big Basket’s decision is akin to an economic boycott is flawed. Some people have suggested that procurement is being specifically targeted to benefit Hindus at the expense of Muslims. However, this viewpoint ignores the facts:
The preference for Halal meat is primarily driven by Muslim consumers, who form a significant portion of the meat market.
Out of the six largest meat suppliers in India, four are Hindu businesses. No Muslim has an aversion to purchasing meat from these Hindu suppliers.
Halal certification is about compliance with religious practices, not about economic discrimination.
False equivalences, like the one suggesting exclusive Halal procurement, equates to spreading hate and misinformation. The reality is that many industries are dominated by certain religious or demographic groups, and this does not inherently mean they are dominating for discriminatory reasons.
The Hygienic and Ethical Standards of Halal Meat
Halal standards are not just about religious practice; they are also about high ethical and hygienic standards:
Animals must live a pure life from birth and be treated with care.
They must not be subjected to abuse, mistreatment, or pain during their lifetime.
They must have access to clean water and food appropriate for their species.
The method of sacrifice must be performed with a sharp object to minimize pain and drain all blood from the body.
These strict standards ensure the meat is healthier and tastier. In light of the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, the importance of such standards cannot be overstated. Halal meat is gaining popularity amid such health challenges due to its superior hygiene and treatment standards.
Adopting the best practices from different religions and cultures can lead to a more progressive and healthier society. Jhatka and Halal are not mutually exclusive; rather, they are part of the diverse practices that make up the fabric of Indian culture.
Conclusion
Understanding the differences between Jhatka and Halal, as well as the debates surrounding Big Basket's decision, is crucial to addressing the issue fairly. While Halal standards are being increasingly adopted, the dominance of Jhatka meat reflects broader socio-economic factors. It is essential to recognize and appreciate the cultural and religious diversity that these practices represent.