Why Alternative Christian Music Isn't (Always) My Cup of Tea: Reflections and Ruminations
Have you ever found yourself torn between two types of music—those that resonate with your faith, and those that simply aren't to your taste? This is a common conundrum faced by many believers, especially when it comes to Christian music. I, for one, have found myself in this predicament.
About My Experience with Christian Music
At one point, I played guitar for my church (though these days, I play only occasionally). There was a particular Christian band that my church was fond of, and they would often select their songs because the lyrics were encouraging and appealing to both the younger and the older generation. However, I must admit that I disliked their music quite strongly. While I found the lyrics acceptable, the musical style did not align with my personal preferences. Like many, I often encounter various musical styles within Christian music, and I tend to define a song as Christian based on the lyrics pointing to Christianity, rather than a specific musical style.
It's important to note that just because I have a particular taste in music, it doesn't diminish the profound impact these songs have on others. In the end, the goal is to honor God, and playing the song with love and purpose is what truly matters.
Why I Prefer Country Music Over Modern Christian Music
It's not every day that I find myself vehemently disagreeing with the popular opinion at church or even during church services. However, one statement that has garnered me quite a bit of attention is my strong preference for country music over modern Christian music. Believe it or not, I often make this claim, even during intense and emotional moments. Is it a shock to hear a staunch rock fan declare their preference for country music? It might be, but I stand by my words.
Here's a lyric you might find intriguing:
"Well my goodness gracious let me tell you the news, my heads been wet with the midnight dew, I've been down on bended knee, talking to the man from Galilee, He spoke to me in the voice so sweet, I thought I heard the shuffle of the angels feet, He called my name and my heart stood still, When he said, 'Johnny go do my will!'"
Who do you think sings this song? It isn't Hillsong, The Newsboys, or Lauren Daigle. The singer is Johnny Cash, and the song is "God's Gonna Cut You Down." This powerful song is from the same man who sang "Cocaine" and "Blues Train." Johnny Cash's mastery of the genre shines through this song, which is a favorite of worship leaders all over the upper Midwest.
"You're a good, good father / It's who you are / It's who you are / It's who you are / I'm loved by you / It's who I am / It's who I am / It's who I am"
How many times have I sung this song? Too many to count. It's become the most overdone message in Christianity, and while I understand that modern Christian music isn't completely without merit, it often defaults to trite metaphors and vague struggles. But let's not throw the baby out with the bathwater—there is still great Christian music out there. For example, "21 Years" by TobyMac is a touching song about a father's faith challenged by the death of his son.
And let's not forget the classic hymns. Songs like "It Is Well with My Soul" by Horatio Spafford are powerful in their depth and meaning. In times of tragedy, such as the loss of a family, they offer solace and strength.
Conclusion: Embracing Diversity in Christian Music
Christian music can take many forms, and it's important that we as believers embrace this diversity. Whether it's the raw authenticity of contemporary Christian music or the timeless beauty of classic hymns, each style has its place. Ultimately, it's not about pleasing oneself but about honoring God, whether through Johnny Cash or your favorite contemporary Christian band. So, while my personal taste might lie with country music, I celebrate the wide range of musical expressions that help others connect with their faith.