Introduction
The debate over who is the better wide receiver between Odell Beckham Jr. (OBJ) and Amari Cooper has been ongoing, and the answer often hinges on their current and past forms. While both players have their strengths, their overall performances and injury records can provide some clarity. This article will delve into the statistics, key statistics, and player comparisons to determine who would be the better choice when fully healthy.
Statistical Comparisons
When fully healthy, OBJ statistically has been the better of the two. His explosive nature and ability to make spectacular plays make him a standout. Despite his talent, Amari Cooper is also a top-tier receiver and in many ways, he just falls slightly below OBJ in terms of overall statistics.
The primary issue with OBJ is his injury history. While he has been in the league for a season longer than Amari, he has played in 12 fewer games due to these injuries. These absences have significantly impacted his longevity and consistency in the NFL.
Career Highlights and Potential
Amari Cooper, while younger, is in his prime right now. He is one of the best route runners in the league and still has the speed to take the top off a defense. On the other hand, OBJ is known for his spectacular catches but lacks the consistent performance of other receivers. His performance has been characterized by inconsistency, with several outstanding seasons interspersed with less successful ones.
Current Performance and Experience
When healthy, OBJ is undoubtedly a force to be reckoned with. His early seasons with the Giants saw him perform at a level that was truly incomparable. OBJ's second season with the Rams was also exceptional, where he thrived under a better quarterback and with a more favorable system. His potential to be one of the top five receivers of all time has been evident in his prime years.
Cooper, while not as spectacular in terms of individual plays, has shown dependability and consistent production. He has been solid and dependable, and his solid performances have often placed him among the top 10 receivers in the league. His decision-making and route-running skills are well respected in the league. In contrast, OBJ's performance can be inconsistent, with periods of brilliance mixed with periods of decline.
System Fit and Performance Factors
The fit within a team's system and the quarterback's performance can have a significant impact on a wide receiver's effectiveness. OBJ's performance was subpar in Cleveland due to the system and quarterback, but he flourished under better situations with the Rams. Similarly, Cooper did very well with the Raiders and under quarterback Derek Carr, until a system change and utilization issues made him less effective.
The key to evaluating a wide receiver's ability is their dependability. Amari Cooper has been more consistent and dependable, producing great numbers even in a system that somewhat hindered his performance in the later part of his time with the Raiders. OBJ, though he can be spectacular at times, is often off the mark and unpredictable.
Conclusion
In terms of dependability, reliability, and consistent performance, Amari Cooper comes out ahead. While OBJ has the potential to be a Hall of Famer when fully healthy, his injury history and inconsistency make it hard to trust him as a long-term top-tier option. Cooper, though not a flashy choice, is a solid and dependable receiver who has the potential to continue being a number-one receiver in the league.
To sum up, while both players have their unique strengths, for teams seeking a reliable and consistent performer, Amari Cooper would be the better choice. His performance history and dependability make him a safer bet for consistent production.