Why Didn't Queen Calanthe Trust Geralt Until Her Demise in The Witcher Series?

The Intense Distrust of Queen Calanthe

Queen Calanthe, as a character in The Witcher series, is an intensely stubborn and self-reliant figure who had reasons to distrust Geralt, a mutant witcher. In a world filled with deviation and danger, she had to be cautious with who she trusted, especially when it came to her granddaughter, Princess Cid. The idea of having her hand over someone she barely knew and who defied her volition was unthinkable for her. This approach to the world, though understandable, is also an ironic display of the bad habits that Geralt has been trying to escape all season: a reflexive self-reliance and an inability to trust in others.

Calanthe's distrust stems from her past experiences. Geralt, despite his proven abilities and dedication to his duties, was once a cause of her frustration and disappointment. He had defied her commands in the past, making her question his loyalty and the sacrifices he was willing to make for her cause.

Self-Reliance and Inability to Trust

Calanthe's marriage to Foltest was marked by a conflict between her protective instincts and Foltest's belief in Geralt. This conflict is evident in Geralt's refusal to follow Calanthe's secret order to kidnap their granddaughter. Foltest believed in Geralt's abilities and his mission, whereas Calanthe was wary, driven by self-reliance and a deep-seated concern for her kin's well-being.

Throughout the series, Geralt's journey is one of learning and self-reflection. He is gradually able to let go of his self-reliant nature, understanding the importance of trust and the value of alliances. However, Calanthe remains resolute in her distrust, driven by her protective instincts and her fear of repeating past mistakes. This stark contrast in their characters highlights the theme of trust and its transformation over the course of the story.

Case of Redania and Geralt's Mission

Calanthe's decision to distrust Geralt is not just rooted in personal experiences but is also influenced by the political landscape of Redania. She understands the danger of the Amell trait, the potential threat it poses, and the responsibility that comes with her position of power. The stakes are high, and her choices are paramount. Geralt's mission to eliminate Cid, driven by historical grievances and a sense of duty to his enemies, further complicate the situation.

The political ramifications of Cid's existence cannot be ignored. As a potential threat or ally, Cid's future depends on the decisions made by those around her, especially Queen Calanthe. Geralt and Calanthe represent two sides of a complex conflict: Geralt acting on revenge and religious convictions, and Calanthe striving for the safety and protection of her people and her family.

Conclusion

The journey of trust between Queen Calanthe and Geralt is a central element of The Witcher series. Calanthe's reluctance to trust Geralt is a reflection of her personal and political fears, while Geralt's struggle with self-reliance symbolizes the broader theme of the series: the importance of trust, alliances, and the willingness to rely on others in a dangerous world. Despite their differences, the two characters' paths intertwine, weaving a complex tapestry of trust, duty, and personal growth.

Final thoughts on the characters and their journey towards understanding and trust:

Geralt's journey towards trusting others is a crucial narrative arc, showing growth and self-awareness. The political and emotional factors that fuel Calanthe's distrust are significant, shaping her decisions and ultimately leading to a tragic end. The relationship between Calanthe and Geralt is a microcosm of the broader themes of loyalty, trust, and the complex nature of human relationships.

Understanding Queen Calanthe's reluctance to trust Geralt until her demise not only provides insights into the story's characters but also enriches the reader's appreciation of the series' intricate layers and profound themes.