The Boy Scouts of America's Decision to Include Transgender Boys: A Responsibility to Inclusive Leadership

After the Boy Scouts of America's (BSA) recent decision to allow transgender boys to join its ranks, much discourse has arisen. I stand firmly in favor of this decision, believing it to be a forward-thinking and inclusive approach that aligns with the values of not only the BSA but society as a whole.

Exclusion vs. Inclusion: The Argument for Inclusion

There are no good reasons to exclude transgender boys from the Boy Scouts. The primary apprehension—whether they will be picked on or not—misses the more vital point. While it's true that some will face bullying, that is an issue that every child encounters in life. The youth should be given the opportunity to make their own choices, with adult support and guidance. It's their decision, and adults should do what they can to ensure all children are safe and treated with respect.

Furthermore, the argument that their participation would lead to 'being picked on' for another two hours per week is utterly baseless. Transgender boys will see the same kids at school, where they are already a part of their daily lives. Is it so unreasonable to believe that they might even experience less bullying overall, as they form friendships and bonds outside of school?

Transgender Inclusivity and Personal Marginalization

It is most unfortunate if, due to being transgender, a boy misses out on the invaluable experiences offered by the Boy Scouts. The experiences, such as ski trips, hikes, whitewater rafting, ice climbing, camping, biking, kayaking, and canoeing, are life-changing. My experience as a Scout left an indelible mark on my life. I learned essential skills, volunteered in various projects, forged new friendships, and developed a sense of accomplishment. These experiences make a huge difference in a young person's life. Denying a child such opportunities due to their gender identity is morally reprehensible.

Positive Values and Life-Saving Skills

The Boy Scouts not only teach basic skills but also instill core values such as trustworthiness, loyalty, and helpfulness. These values are crucial for forming well-rounded individuals. The Scouts in Action comics, featured in the BSA magazine Boys’ Life, showcase real-life stories of Scouts helping their communities, often employing the skills they learned through the organization. These stories serve as a powerful example of social responsibility and heroism.

I am deeply moved by the courageous actions of a young boy who saved his entire family, a feat that exemplifies the values promoted by the Boy Scouts. It is my belief that we should strive to instill these values in as many children as possible, encouraging them to be the best versions of themselves and to contribute positively to society.

Another reason for this decision is the potential impact on the lives of others. Some individuals may have been saved from life-threatening situations due to the lifesaving skills imparted during their time in the Boy Scouts. Therefore, excluding a child who wants to learn and grow within this framework can be ethically troubling. The BSA should not deny children the opportunity to develop skills that could potentially save lives.

Conclusion: A Gift of Opportunity

The Boy Scouts of America's inclusion of transgender boys not only fosters a more inclusive and respectful environment but also provides these boys with a unique opportunity to grow and thrive. The organization has played a significant role in shaping my life, and I believe it should continue to do so for all those who wish to participate. Inclusivity and positive values are the core of the BSA's mission, and they will make a profound difference in the lives of the young people they serve.