Reflections on Popular Guitar Methods and Techniques: A Wreath of Bad Habits in Guitar Instruction

Guitar instruction has evolved significantly with the advent of the internet, making it easier for aspiring guitarists to access a wealth of information and tutorials. However, the abundance of instructional materials and methods also brings about the risk of developing poor habits. This article explores some of the popular guitar methods and techniques that have contributed to a "wreath of bad habits" in guitar teaching and offers insights into how students and teachers can avoid these pitfalls.

The Internet's Impact on Guitar Instruction

The internet has undeniably had a transformative effect on guitar instruction, providing a vast array of resources and tutorials. Younger guitarists often indulge in advanced techniques, influenced by the wealth of online content. While this accessibility is a double-edged sword, it can be harnessed responsibly. The challenge lies in ensuring that these resources are used effectively and that students develop sound playing habits.

Many teachers and aspiring instructors contribute quality tips and techniques, which can greatly benefit students. However, there is a notable risk of user error in instructional content. Some teachers rely on tablature and exact replicas of other players' arrangements, which can be limiting and potentially harmful if not balanced with fundamental skills. It is essential for both teachers and students to challenge these methods and seek a balanced approach to learning.

Popular Methods and Their Pitfalls

One widely adopted method is the use of tablature and learning songs by exact arrangement. While this can be a useful starting point, it often leads to a narrow approach to guitar playing. Using songs to teach technique diversifies the learning experience and helps students apply what they learn to a broader range of music. This approach not only enhances technique but also fosters creativity and versatility.

Another critical issue is the ergonomic position of the hands, as highlighted by the example of the Berklee College of Music's bass teaching methods. A poor left-hand position, with the wrist bent at an almost 90-degree angle, can lead to long-term strain and injury. It underscores the importance of proper technique and the potential consequences of relying on materials that do not prioritize ergonomic principles. Teachers and students should be aware of the long-term implications of playing technique and seek resources that promote healthy playing habits.

Individual Techniques and Their Critiques

One technique that stands out as potentially detrimental is tapping. While tapping can add flair and serve as a tool when your fretting hand is not up to par, it can also be a crutch. Tapping sequences from the 7 major scale modes, while useful, can become a lazy alternative to learning how to finger out the notes manually. This reliance on tapping over manual practice can stifle the development of essential skills and lead to a superficial understanding of the fretboard.

Towards a Balanced Approach to Guitar Instruction

To avoid these bad habits, a balanced approach is essential. Teachers and students should focus on building a strong foundation of technique, theory, and musical understanding. This involves more than just playing the latest licks or replicating famous solos. Instead, it is about fostering a deep connection with the instrument and the music. Encouraging students to experiment with different techniques and to understand the underlying theory can help them develop a more versatile and sustainable skill set.

Moreover, embracing a holistic approach to guitar playing can lead to healthier playing habits. This includes regular exercises to improve finger dexterity, stamina, and endurance, as well as mindfulness practices to enhance mental focus and technique. Teachers should prioritize ergonomics, encouraging students to use tools like wrist rests and ergonomic picks to prevent strain and ensure long-term playing health.

In conclusion, while the internet has provided a wealth of resources for guitar instruction, it is crucial to approach these resources with a critical eye. By prioritizing a balanced, healthy, and sustainable approach to technique and ergonomics, both teachers and students can avoid the pitfalls of bad habits and develop a truly enriching guitar playing experience.