Phillips Andover Academy vs. Phillips Exeter Academy: A Conservative Outlook

When debating the question of which is more conservative, Philips Andover Academy or Philips Exeter Academy, the surface-level visibility might not be enough. One way to gauge the true temperament of a school is by examining their recommended summer reading lists, which provide a glimpse into their values and aspirations for their students.

Personal Insights into the Dynamics at Both Academies

As a former student of Philips Andover Academy from 1961 to 1965, I have a unique perspective on the dynamics that were prevalent during my time. It's important to acknowledge that societies evolve over time, and so do institutions like these prestigious academies. Furthermore, my experience was shaped by my background, which was working-class, and my active involvement in sports and the arts.

Philips Andover Academy and Philips Exeter Academy have both historically prided themselves on attracting a diverse population. With a cross-section of students from various socioeconomic backgrounds, it's not uncommon to find a mix of wealthy and upper-middle-class students, many of whom were affiliated with conservative circles. However, the presence of liberal students was also significant, particularly from the "upper-middle class" category.

The Sentiment of Conservatism in the Upper Classes

During my time at Andover, it was apparent that there was a strong presence of nascent conservatives in the student body. Wealthier students often belonged to certain conservative-leaning groups, and there were occasional liberal students from affluent families, even if they preferred to downplay their wealth. It’s important to note that during that period, the line between working-class and middle-class students was not as clear-cut as the poster child of conservative families might imagine.

There were instances where wealthy but liberal students were sometimes referred to as “Limousine Liberals” by their conservative counterparts. One such example was Alex, the grandson of Margaret Sanger. His liberal views were not a surprise to his wealthy conservative family, and he even invited me to Sunday brunch with his family, where I was greeted with warmth and respect.

The Evolving Landscape of Phillips Academies

Taking a look at the current state of the Phillips Academies shows a significant shift towards inclusivity. Both schools now aim to attract promising students from a broader socioeconomic range, including those from the "bottom quarter." This effort is commendable, but it also means that well-funded and well-heeled students will continue to comprise a substantial portion of the student body.

Conclusion: A Balanced Reflection on Both Academies

In conclusion, while both Philips Andover Academy and Philips Exeter Academy have a rich tapestry of student cultures, conservatism has historically been more prevalent among the wealthy students. However, this does not imply a uniformity of values or beliefs among all students. As alumni, we play a crucial role in supporting these institutions, acknowledging their contributions, and recognizing the importance of maintaining a balanced and inclusive academic environment.

Good luck to you, whichever Phillips Academy you choose to attend. Both institutions are well-worth the investment of time, effort, and resources, and I am confident they will continue to be so.