Is 'Splash' Too Good to Remake?

The question of whether to remake Splash (1984) is not whether the original was 'too good'. Instead, the key is whether potential remakes can add value, offer a fresh perspective, or improve upon the narrative.

The Case Against Simply Remaking

Movie remakes often face significant challenges. For instance, Psycho (1960) is a classic that sets the bar high. While Psycho (1998) attempted to recapture its essence, the director, Gus Van Sant, fell short in bringing any new elements that enhanced the story. This remake was deemed unnecessary and even flawed.

The Success of Remakes: A Case Study of 'The Maltese Falcon'

On the other hand, remakes like The Maltese Falcon (1941) have succeeded because they offered something new, primarily through the direction of John Huston and the starring role of Humphrey Bogart. Similarly, the remake of Zero Hour! in 1980, known as Airplane!, stands as a comedic classic, indicating that remakes can indeed become better versions of their contenders.

The Move to Remake 'True Grit'

The 2010 remake of True Grit by the Coen brothers demonstrates another successful approach to remaking a film. While the 1969 version starring John Wayne was already well-loved, the Coen brothers chose to re-envision the story, leading to a critically acclaimed film that reinterpreted the source material in a modern context.

'Splash': A Childhood Classic

Splash (1984) holds a special place in the hearts of many, not just because of its fantasy elements but also due to its memorable cast and creative team. The film was not an adaptation from a book but an original story that was nominated for an Academy Award for Best Original Screenplay. Not only did it appeal to audiences but it also marked a significant shift in Disney's strategy, being their first film under the Touchstone Pictures label aimed at adult themes. The combination of top-notch talent, including actors like Tom Hanks, Daryl Hannah, and John Candy, made Splash a beloved classic with a 92% rating on Rotten Tomatoes.

Reimagining for a New Generation

With the new remake set to reverse the genders and feature Channing Tatum as the merman and Jillian Bell as Tom Hanks' original character, there is a potential for a fresh interpretation that could resonate with a new generation. The focus, however, is not on simply matching or surpassing the original but on offering a unique reimagining that brings new characters and storylines to the forefront.

Timing and Competition

The release timing for the new Splash remake could also play a crucial role in its success. With Warner Bros. planning to release Aquaman, competition from the box office could affect promotional efforts and audience attention. Making the film as distinctive as possible and positioning it with a compelling storyline and creative direction could help it stand out in a crowded theatrical landscape.

Conclusion

In the world of cinema, remakes are more about re-envisioning and adding new life to a story rather than merely recreating what already exists. With the right approach, 'Splash' has the potential to remain a beloved classic, even in its new form. The key is whether the remake can bring something fresh to the table, rather than merely being a copy of its predecessor.