Is Something Called a Grammatically Correct Phrase?

When we scrutinize the structure of a sentence in isolation, it might seem overly simple, but delve deeper, and you'll find a rich tapestry of linguistic complexity. This article explores the nuances of a phrase like “something is called” and whether it can be considered grammatically correct.

The Semantics of Incomplete Phrases

Take, for example, the phrase 'something is called'. It is not merely a random string of words; it exists within a broader context. In isolation, it may appear cryptic and devoid of meaning, but in its usage within sentences, it can serve a purpose. For instance, consider the colloquial term 'thingamajig' or 'whatchamacallit', which both derive from similar constructions. These terms are often used to describe an object whose name can't be readily recalled.

Grammatical Structure and Function

From a grammatical perspective, 'something is called' can indeed be considered a sentence and, consequently, grammatically correct. It features a subject ('something') and a verb ('is called'). While it lacks a direct object, the verb 'called' can imply the existence of a name, whether known or unknown.

However, the phrase lacks context and often leaves the reader confused. It is more of an incomplete thought or an introductory clause rather than a complete sentence. To illustrate this, consider the following sentence: 'Every morning around sunrise I wake up and…well someone is calling my name. Of course I can't be sure of it but I could swear my name is called. Or at least something is called.' Here, the phrase 'something is called' sets the stage for a fragment of a sentence that continues to form a complete narrative.

Examples of Grammatically Correct Phrases

Despite the lack of formal meaning, 'something is called' is grammatically correct in certain contexts. For instance, when used in phrases like "My cat is called Tibby" or "Aberdeen is called 'The Granite City'," or "Boris Johnson is often called 'Bojo.'", the phrase serves as a descriptor or a colloquial reference. These examples demonstrate that the phrase can be used effectively to convey information or to refer to a known or unknown name.

The phrase 'something is called' can also be used in more complex sentences to introduce a concept or to set up a discussion. For example:

'Something is called a thingamajig when you can guess at its function but can't remember its name.' 'Some believe that something is called a prime number if it has exactly two distinct positive divisors.'

In these contexts, the phrase 'something is called' introduces a definition or a concept, making it a valuable and grammatically sound element of the sentence.

Conclusion

In summary, 'something is called' is indeed a grammatically correct phrase, at least in certain contexts. While it lacks a literal meaning when considered on its own, it can be used in conjunction with other words to convey meaningful information. Understanding the context and the intended use of the phrase is crucial to its effective communication.