Has Game of Thrones Lost Its Realism and Predictability?

Game of Thrones (GoT) has been a phenomenon that captivated millions with its intricate plotlines, memorable characters, and unpredictable outcomes. However, as seasons progressed, many fans argue the show has lost its way. This article will explore whether GoT has indeed stopped making sense, focusing on its realism, predictability, and the transition from books to television.

Realism and Unpredictability

One of the most appealing aspects of Game of Thrones was its commitment to realism and unpredictability. The show managed to kill off key characters, such as Ned Stark, Robb Stark, Khal Drogo, Joffrey, and Tywin Lannister, while still maintaining a coherent narrative. The audience was left stunned and eager to see how the story would unfold without these foundational characters.

However, with the revival of Jon Snow from the dead, the show seems to have veered towards a more populist direction. While some major characters, like Tyrion Lannister, have made influential statements, the focus has shifted away from the intricate character development that defined the early seasons. For example, there has been a notable lack of major character deaths in the last two seasons, and the introduction of the dragons has only added to the puzzle.

Predictability and Idealism

Many fans have raised concerns about the show becoming more idealistic and predictable. The first two episodes of Season 8 were particularly disappointing, with reunions that lacked emotional impact. This shift from the narrative's realism to more idealistic outcomes has made the show less engaging for some viewers. If the idealism is too strong, some may wonder if a show like The Lord of the Rings (LOTR) might be a better fit, given its more cohesive and predictable storyline.

My own perspective on the show's realism remains strong, particularly in the earlier seasons. Characters' storylines and situations all made sense to me, even if they were exaggerated. Expecting a show that hatched three dragons to be over the top is understandable, but it is a testament to the show's ability to create a rich, fantastical world.

Transition from Books to Television

The transition from book storylines to the HBO adaptation has been a topic of much conversation. The earlier books established the characters and major plotlines, but the last book or two veered off into multiple directions, diluting the narrative. Game of Thrones adapted many of these storylines successfully, but as the show progressed, the focus seemed to shift, with the Dorne storylines causing frustration for many.

By the end of Season 6, the show seemed to be pulling the plotlines together, with characters heading towards reunions and confrontations that would advance the narrative. This editorial decision by the showrunners has garnered praise for maintaining a coherent direction for the remaining seasons, which had the potential to resolve the many loose ends and culminate in a satisfying conclusion.

Conclusion

While Game of Thrones has had moments where it has veered towards idealism and predictability, it has also maintained its realism and unpredictability, which have kept audiences engaged and passionate. The transition from books to television has been mostly successful, managing to combine the rich storytelling of the books with a disciplined narrative approach that has kept the story on track for a final, satisfying resolution.

Ultimately, whether Game of Thrones has lost its way depends on one's perspective. For those who appreciate the show's commitment to its world and characters, it remains a valuable and thought-provoking piece of television. For others, the idealism and predictability may be the deciding factors in deciding whether or not to continue watching.