Does Stray Kids Deserve to Win AGEO's Kingdom?

The debate over whether or not Stray Kids should have won AGEO's Kingdom is a contentious one. Many fans and critics alike feel that Stray Kids had a well-deserved victory, given their consistent performance and genuine talent. This article delves into the various factors that support this argument, as well as some criticisms that arise from the show's structure and judging criteria.

Why Stray Kids Deserve the Win

Stray Kids has established a reputation for delivering top-tier performances on the stage. Their ability to captivate both judges and audiences with their versatility and raw talent is undeniable. From their unique sounds to their dynamic choreographies, each performance seems tailored to showcase their strengths fully. This consistency in quality, coupled with their strong ranking from both judges and other contestants, makes it hard to argue against their win.

Moreover, Stray Kids faced insider struggles, much like other groups, which further adds weight to their well-deserved triumph. The pressure of navigating such a competitive environment emphasizes the importance of their victory. Each of their members has demonstrated incredible dedication and talent, making it clear that they deserve the accolades they received.

Performance Credentials

The group's carefully considered performances and songs indicate that they are a group based on talent and hard work. According to statistics, Stray Kids often placed first or second on the chart based on judge scores and public votes. Even without their fanbase's influence, it is clear that the judges recognized their exceptional musical contributions. This underscores their professionalism and the quality of their performance, making their victory a symbol of their hard-earned success.

Critical Thoughts on the Show's Judgment and Structure

While supporting Stray Kids' win, it's important to address the criticisms surrounding the show's structure and judging criteria. The inclusion of rookies as judges in early rounds sparked controversy. While the first three rounds featured idol judges, subsequent rounds brought in more rookies, and even choreographers like Lia Kim, which raised doubts about their expertise. There is a strong argument that inviting professional judges with diverse expertise would have provided a more balanced and accurate assessment of the performances.

Furthermore, the lack of transparency regarding the judges' identities and their criteria for evaluation is a point of contention. Fans and even contestants deserve to know the qualifications and perspectives of those evaluating their efforts. The number of points awarded for choreographic elements, visual appeal, and lack of emphasis on live vocal performances seem to weigh heavily, which somewhat detracts from the overall authenticity of the judging process.

The Importance of Live Vocal and Conceptual Performance

Performances are not solely about visual appeal and choreography; the live vocal aspect is equally crucial. For example, the BTOB cover of "Back Door" showcased impressive live vocal abilities, a concept that was both interesting and unique. However, it received less recognition due to the judges' focus on visual and choreographic elements. Utilizing different judges for specific aspects of the performance could have provided a more comprehensive evaluation.

The implied and complex concepts of certain groups, like Stray Kids, may be challenging for judges who do not have access to behind-the-scenes insights. Providing such information could help judges better understand the depth of the group's performances, giving them a more informed perspective.

Conclusion: A Comprehensive Consideration

While there is a strong case for Stray Kids' deserved win, it is crucial to consider all aspects of the show to appreciate its complexity. The show’s criteria and judges' composition need to be more transparent and balanced. Until then, fans and critics will continue to debate the factors that contribute to the final win. Regardless, the performances of Stray Kids and other groups offer invaluable insights into the incredible talent and dedication of K-pop idols.